One example of the difficulty in beating a passively managed
benchmark or
fund: The DFA Large Value Fund (passively managed) ranked #12 of 349* US large
value funds for the ten years ending March 2006, produced 11.74% annualized
return, 3.40% annualized better return than the
group average. The #1 ranked fund, the FAM Value Fund produced just .74% better
annualized return. However, the return for the
full common time
period of the two funds (April 1993-March 2006) shows the FAM Value Fund underperformed the DFA Large Value fund by .53% annualized, hardly inspiring the idea of
value added associated with skillful
management.
*Source: Morningstar March 2006